Cynical Or Just Smart?
Posted By Kristabella on December 1, 2010
Last Saturday night, I went out with my stepmom and my sisters to celebrate my youngest half-sister’s birthday. She turned 18. I cannot put into words how old that makes me feel. She’s legal! That little baby! How is that possible?
In honor of her birthday, we went to dinner on the street that shares her name:

(Actually, it was a total coincidence. But that didn’t stop us from making her climb a pole.)
After dinner we went downtown to look at the lights and the decorations in the windows on Michigan Avenue. I ended up driving, so I parked in a parking garage. I am too impatient to look for street parking downtown. And since I got a free meal, I was OK paying for parking.
After freezing our butts off outside, we decided to call it a night. My stepmom, sisters, et al headed back to their car (my stepmom’s boyfriend DOES look for street parking downtown) and I headed to mine in the garage. It was a very well-lit garage, one you had to pay before you went back to your car.
I went to the lobby to pay and as I got off the elevator, there was a guy standing by the pay machines. He seemed normal enough, had a cup of Starbucks coffee in his hand. As I approached, he asked for $4. The parking was $14 and I guess he was $4 short. I told him I had no cash and proceeded to pay my parking fee with a credit card.
He then proceeded to tell me he tried to pay with his card, but he was overdrawn because of some large car loan or something. I tried to hurry up and pay without seeming freaked out. I was like “oh man, I hear ya! Money troubles suck! Yuck!”
Then he kept asking if I had any other bills, because he could make change for me. I told him I didn’t have any cash on me. It was actually a lie because I had $40 in my wallet to pay for my cabs on Sunday to and from the bar. But I wasn’t going to give him that money. I just wanted to get to my car and get home.
We rode the elevator together. He was one floor below me and got off and went to his car. I wished him luck and headed up to my floor to my car.
As I was driving home, I was kind of mad at myself because here it is the holiday season and I couldn’t spare any money for this poor guy? I mean, I have $14. I could have paid his parking fee so he could have gotten his car out. Pay it forward and all that. Why am I such a cynic that I assume everyone is bad and going to attack me? Wouldn’t I have wanted someone to help me out if I was in the same situation? Where’s my good cheer and helping out the common man?
But I always trust my gut. And something about this situation seemed shady. I’m pretty sure the fact that I was VISIBLY carrying my pepper spray helped me avoid a bad situation. It was later in the evening. There was no one in that garage. He could have easily followed me to my car and done things I don’t even want to think about.
On top of it, who parks in a parking garage in the city of Chicago, DOWNTOWN, when you know you don’t have money? I mean, you had enough money for coffee at Starbucks. And why are you asking for $4, yet have change for bigger bills, if I had them? Were you waiting for me to put my guard down and open my wallet and then you would attack?
WHY IS THAT MY FIRST THOUGHT?
I am a generous person. I am generous with my time, my money, etc. I love giving, be it hugs or cupcakes. I have no issue with being generous. I give to charities. And I would rather do that, or give a dollar to a bum on the street, than have given this dude money in this situation. Yeah, it may come back to bite me in the ass karmically, but I would rather be a cynic than be beat up and thrown in a trunk of some random dude’s car.
So am I just way too cynical? Has years of city living jaded me? Or does my being jaded and cynical keep me safer?
:::
Edited to add: I would like to ease all your fears that getting in the elevator with him was not by choice. I tried stalling as long as I could. The longer I stalled, the longer he stalled. And rather than go into a creepy staircase with him following me, I thought going in the elevator CLEARLY armed with my pepper spray was better. Trust me, I have already told myself that if something similar happens again, I’ll claim I need to go outside to get something, ANYTHING.










