My First (And Probably Last) Book Review
Posted By Kristabella on December 18, 2008
I was recently asked to review a book for my site called You Lost Him At Hello by Jess McCann. At first I was all excited because I love chick lit! Then I READ the email and realized this was a relationship/self-helpy book. (*groan*) So I was originally going to say no because I’ve seen all the Sex & The City episodes. I know all there is to know about dating. That is, if I ever went on dates.
But then I agreed because maybe I’m making some grave error and I could totally learn a thing or two from a book. And then I could pass on this wisdom to all my single ladies. And if you like it then you shoulda put a ring on it. And other Beyonce lyrics.
So I agreed. And then I got the book and all its PR materials. And then I was like “You Lost Me At The Press Release!” But I agreed to read the book and give it an honest review. Which is kind of what I’m doing. And will probably not land me any more reviews in the near future.
First, I’ll start with the bad stuff. Because whenever I have a job review they always start with the good stuff and end with the bad stuff. And then you end up walking out of the room in tears wondering why on Earth anyone would employ you with all your faults and such.
The biggest thing I disliked about this book is that the major theme of it is that if you want to land a man, you have to play games. You always have to look your best, act your best and be a total game player. And I know I’m single and have no prospects, so maybe that is what I’m doing wrong. But if I have to do all that “waiting to call him back and pretending you’re uninterested and are too busy for him” game, I’m not interested in a finding a man. I believe you don’t have to play games to find the man of your dreams. I know plenty of people in wonderful, loving relationships that didn’t have an ounce of game play. I’m too old for games.
To be honest, I wanted to give up on this book on page 6. I didn’t. While it has its flaws, it does have some good points too. There were a few times where I read something in this book that you shouldn’t do, things that freak the shit out of dudes, and realized that I did that thing (or things) in a past relationship.
The idea of the book is to sell yourself to a potential mate. Makes complete sense. Because really, dating isn’t much different that a job interview, right? You’re trying to sell your best qualities so you get hired. Or betrothed. This is good advice for anything you do in life. And it starts with having self-confidence, which I agree with McCann, is very important in relationships (and life in general).
In the book, McCann talks about the SEE Factor. It’s a way to engage men in public places and get their attention and let them know you are interested. The idea is when you see a guy you like, smile, make eye contact and exude positive energy. I honestly believe this will work, if I could ever work up the nerve to test it out. I’m afraid my venture into this would result in some sort of creepy smile and stalkery staring, instead of making eye contact and giving a casual, flirty smile.
Overall, the book gives some good tips. There are the obvious ones, the ones so many of us forget about when we start dating someone new- like not sleeping with someone on the first date or not getting hammered on a date. A lot of these things we do as women are common mistakes and can send a dude running for the hills.
Obviously a lot of the things in this book that are big no-nos are also things you learn as you experience life and mature. Things you can’t learn from books. Things you do when you’re 22, whether it be in dating or in your career or just in life in general, are a lot stupider than things you do when you’re 32. But at the time, they SEEM like good ideas. That’s what life is all about, experiencing and growing and learning from the past.
So my verdict is that the book was meh. It definitely wasn’t for me, but I probably picked up a tip or two.
But maybe you’ll like it! So if this lovely review has intrigued you and you’d like to win my copy of this book, please let me know in the comments and I’ll do a drawing and choose a winner.
(And then after you read it, we can exchange emails and talk about how we really feel about this book. Doesn’t that sound like fun?)



